In my Nov. 8 column in the Colorado Springs Gazette, and at www.gazette.com, I write about the Vatican’s investigation of U.S. sisterhoods, including Benet Pines and Mount St. Francis monasteries in Colorado Springs.
Some experts think the investigation is driven by U.S. sisters’ embrace of the liberal decisions of Vatican II, while priests have tended to embrace pre-Vatican II ideas, which are far more conservative.
To read what the Vatican says about the investigation, go to www.apostolicvisitation.org.
Below is an edited excerpt of my interview with a Catholic expert about the controversy.
Mary Louise Hartman is the former president of the Association for the Rights of Catholics in the Church, based in St. Louis.
MARK BARNA: Why is the Vatican investigating U.S. sisterhoods?
HARTMAN: It’s just another effort of the curia, or (Vatican) middle management, to annoy the American church. They are not happy with the way we practice Catholicism. I sense that those in the curia want to maintain the status quo of the late 19th century. They don’t want to move out of Vatican I.
BARNA: Why are U.S. nuns the focus?
HARTMAN: The nuns are more visible, active, vocal, successful.
BARNA: What bugs you the most about the inquiry?
HARTMAN: It is stupid. It was done without consultation. The process is undemocratic. They are treating these women like children. It makes it even worse that they haven’t done the same investigation of priests, especially given the pedophilia scandals. [Editor's note:About seven years ago, the Vatican investigated seminaries. The scuttlebutt at the time was that authorities were trying to root out gays within the seminaries. No results were published publicly about that investigation.]











